Toyota FTW! I had a Suburban way back when (1999) I got a 2003 4Runner (2wd) and that thing is SOLID as a ROCK and not a chevy rock I'm talking a real rock! My DD is a company car, Toyota Prius. Yea, go ahead and laugh.. 45 mpg with my foot plowed into it all day. The car is very peppy, roomy and extremely reliable. This is my 3rd Prius as a company car, having totaled 1, sold the 2nd to my uncle and plan to buy out the one I'm in when it's time. I am partial to Toyota (my parent company) but you can't go wrong with Honda, Kia, Hyundai and Nissan.
Stay away from Mitsubishi (quality) & Subaru (repair cost).