the tire place is going on the recommended size rim for that tire size. going with the recommended size rim you will be able to run the recommended tire pressure for your vehicle for normal wear and tear. now a narror rim and a wide tire is going to buldge more so your going to have to run a lower pressure on the street in order to get a good contact with the road which will lead to a little more slop in the handeling (probley not enough to notice on a DD with the tire size in question). off road as said above it should help keep the tire seated a little better at lower pressures. if it was me i would go with the 8" rims, in fact that is what i'm running currently running with 36" IROKs (sort of), when i bought them they were 15x8 then i added DIY Bead locks which makes them closer to a 9" rim now.